Disclaimer

This blog is an assignment for CMP 272 Spring A 2009 to allow students an opportunity to present a valid argument, generate feedback (pro and con), post responses, and practice moderating skills in a technological environment.

Thesis

People with HIV/AIDS, or any other contagious disease that can harm health care workers, should have a symbol or code on their ID.

Should AIDS patients have a notification on their ID's?

HIV is a virus that damages human immune cells, weakens the immune system, and without treatment develops into AIDS. HIV infects the cells of a living organism in order to make copies of itself. The virus can only be transmitted in certain ways. HIV is found in blood and other body fluids. It can't live for long outside the body.

The most common ways that people become infected with HIV are:
* having sexual intercourse with an infected partner
* injecting drugs using a needle/syringe thats been used by an infected person
* as a baby of an infected mother, during pregnancy, labor or delivery, or through breastfeeding.

Up until December 2006, their were 57 reported occupational HIV infections. Additionally, 140 possible occupational transmissions have accured among health care personnel.

If precautions are taken with everyone, healthcare workers don't have to make assumptions about people's lifestyles and risk of infection. Health care workers should have the right to be able to protect themselves against infection, whether it is HIV, Hepatitis, or any contagious disease.

Consider the case below.

"I am a lab tech. I worked 11-7 shift for the past 9 and a half years. My job includes drawing blood, testing blood and urine samples in a hospital laboratory, and preparing blood transfusions for patients who need blood products. On 12/31/1993 at 3:55 a.m. I was called to the emergency room to draw blood on a HIV+ drug abuser, it seems she was out of cash but wanted more 'pain meds". The doctors wanted blood tests first to find out what was she sick with. I ended up trying to draw her blood and she became violent, jerking her arm around after I had a needle in her veinand was getting blood out of her arm. She managed to get the dirty needle and stabbed it into my left thumb. When I saw that needle in my hand I felt a chill go down my spine and dreaded I would become positive too.

"Well by March of 1994 I was HIV+. Since then I have tried many of the HIV meds on the market. Many have given me allergic reactions, some have simply been ineffective, others the virus has grown resistant to. It's a month to month battle. So far my t counts are holding and my viral load is between non detected and 10,000. I am married and had a son aged 18 months at the time I was infected. He's now 9.5 years old and the pride of my life. How can I ever tell him mom may not be around much longer? On October 28, 2000 we were blessed with the birth of a daughter. Beautiful is her description by anyone who has seen her. Tonight I received the results of her 1 year HIV test. It is positive."


As of 2008, 36 states in America criminalized the transmission of exposure of HIV, with many having laws specifically mentioning HIV:
* Alabama- Class C misdemenour
* California- Felony punishable by up to 8 years
* Colorado- Class 5 and 6 felonies
* Flordia
* Michigan
* Missouri- Class A or B felony
* New York- Reckless endangerment
* Pennsylvania- Reckless endangerment
* Texas- Aggravated assault

Because people with HIV/AIDS often choose to hide their condition and to protect those who care for the sick, people with HIV/AIDS or any other contagious disease that can harm health care workers should have a symbol or code on their ID.



Monday, May 11, 2009

I think that if they do have hiv/aids their should be a sign on their licences or they should tell you so you can take extra percautions

This is Scary

While I can see the reasons behind knowing people's HIV status, putting it on your ID is a terrible violation of privacy. Read the HIPPA rules before considering this. Also, does every bank teller, grocery store cashier, and the entire DMV need to know my business? It's not like it's secret. People can and will know what that symbol or code means.

Also, should other conditions be listed? Tuberculosis, hepatitis, and more are contagious; should those be listed as well? How much of your medical history should everyone get to know? Remember that diabetics and epileptics wear notifiers to protect themselves, not to warn people off. It just sounds too much like the Scarlet Letter.

Medical professionals should recognize the risk in what they do. When you intentionally work around people with HIV, swine flu, and TB the risks are of your own choosing. The lady quoted should consider HER culpability in having an HIV positive baby. She coldly calculated the chance of infecting someone, while the drug addict was thoughtless and strung out. Which is worse?

Thursday, May 7, 2009

Nakita doesn't have HIV!

..so, I'm not in the medical field nor will I ever be, but I think a symbol for an incurable disease on an ID wouldn't be that helpful. I have been to the doctor many times in my 19 years and never have I been asked to show them my ID. It is very unfortunate what happened to that lady, but it was kind of inevitable. She had no way to stop the patient's actions. People with HIV should know that they are able to share this with their doctor, because everything is kept confidential. Maybe test all of the patients and keep it for your own records?..
Diabetics wear bracelets and people with severe allergies wear bracelets to inform the healthcare providor with the information they need. Why should it be different for AIDS patients. That is important information that the providors need to know, not only for their own protection but for the patients as well. What if the doctor administered a drug that reacts badly to one of the meds they are already on? Thats a lot of responsibility to put on the healthcare providor's shoulders and it wouldn't even be their fault.-

Lynettes opinion

I agree with you. I think that if you have this disease or virus healthcare workers should know. It is scary to think that people are more willing to infect healthcare workers than tell them because of privacy. My sister is a nurse and it is a scary situation to think that she has to worry about this all the time. Good job guys, very good points.

Michelle Opinion

I feel that there should be some kind of symbol on the license, what if that patient comes in and is unconscious and cant tell you they have HIV. The safety of the health care providers is needed in todays world.

Shanna says

While I do understand the danger that many healthcare workers face because of this dreaded and very deadly disease, I think that a code or symbol on their ID could potentially be more detrimental to THEM. The people that have this disease or any other go through enough bias.

Kim's Opinion

I do thnk there should some form of identification that tells a health care professional whether or not they are in contact with someone who has a disease like AIDS. But in the end you have to worry about privacy laws that protect the patient or individual which kind of sucks. I know I would want to know.

Gina's Opinion

I feel that HIV/AIDS patients should have some kind of symbol on their ID to identify them if they are unable to tell people. I also think that if they cause the deliberate infection of another person they should be criminaly charged and punished.

Blog Is Now Open!

This blog is now ready for comments and for poll questions to be answered. Thank You :)

Wednesday, April 22, 2009

Blog Under Construction

This blog is under construction. When it is ready for posting you will be advised.